57
views
0
recommends
+1 Recommend
1 collections
    0
    shares

      From January 2024, all of our readers will be able to access every part of ROAPE as well as its archive without a paywall. This will make ROAPE accessible to a much wider readership, especially in Africa. We need subscriptions and donations to make this revolutionary intiative work. 

      Subscribe and Donate now!

       

      scite_
       
      • Record: found
      • Abstract: found
      • Article: found
      Is Open Access

      Happy ever after in the marketplace: non‐government organisations and uncivil society

      Published
      research-article
      a
      Review of African Political Economy
      Review of African Political Economy
      Bookmark

            Abstract

            This following declaration, about NGOs and civil society, is typical of the hallowed tones used to discuss both. This article sets out to examine what I have called the ‘NGO phenomenon’ which has arisen in the last decade. It is not a critique of NGOs per se,but a critique of the way in which development policy has focused on NGOs, to the extent that expectations of NGO performance are unrealistically high and exclude other options for development.

            Content

            Author and article information

            Journal
            crea20
            CREA
            Review of African Political Economy
            Review of African Political Economy
            0305-6244
            1740-1720
            March 1997
            : 24
            : 71
            : 11-34
            Affiliations
            a University of Sussex
            Article
            8704236 Review of African Political Economy, Vol. 24, No. 71, March 1997, pp. 11-34
            10.1080/03056249708704236
            657d884e-6573-486c-bedd-121ecf0feff9

            All content is freely available without charge to users or their institutions. Users are allowed to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to the full texts of the articles in this journal without asking prior permission of the publisher or the author. Articles published in the journal are distributed under a http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.

            History
            Page count
            Figures: 0, Tables: 0, References: 82, Pages: 24
            Categories
            Original Articles

            Sociology,Economic development,Political science,Labor & Demographic economics,Political economics,Africa

            Bibliography

            1. Ake C. . 1995. . “‘The Democratisation of Disempowerment in Africa’. ”. In The Democratisation of Disempowerment. The Problem of Democracy in the Third World . , Edited by: Hippler J. . London : : Pluto Press. .

            2. Avina J. . 1993. . The evolutionary life‐cycles of non‐government development organisations’. . Public Administration and Development . , Vol. 13:: 453

            3. Bartelson J. . 1995. . “Cambridge Studies in International Relations. ”. In A Genealogy of Sovereignty . , Cambridge : : Cambridge University Press. .

            4. Bayart J‐F. . 1986. . “‘Civil Society in Africa’. ”. In Political Domination in Africa . , p. 99 Cambridge : : Cambridge University Press. .

            5. Beckman B. . 1993. . ‘The Liberation of Civil Society: Neo‐liberal Ideology and Political Theory’. . Review of African Political Economy . , November;

            6. Beiner R. , ed. 1995. . “‘Political Theory, Contemporary Issues’. ”. In Theorizing Citizen‐ship . , New York : : State University of New York Press. .

            7. Billis D and MacKeith J. . 1993. . “‘Organising NGOs Challenges and Trends in the Management of Overseas Aid’. ”. Centre for Voluntary Organisation, London School of Economics. .

            8. Brinkerhoff D and Goldsmith A. . 1992. . ‘Promoting the Sustainability of Development Institutions: A Framework for Strategy’. . World Development . , Vol. 20((3)): 369

            9. Butcher H, Collis P. . 1980. . Community Groups in Action: Case Studies and Analysis . , London : : Routledge and Kegan Paul. .

            10. Buyck B. . 1991. . “‘The Bank's Use of Technical Assistance for Institutional Development’. ”. The World Bank. .

            11. Carroll T. . 1992. . Intermediary NGOs: The Supporting Link in Grassroots Development . , West Hartford , Connecticut : : Kumarian Press. .

            12. Chabal P. . 1992. . Power in Africa . , London : : The Macmillan Press Ltd.. .

            13. Clark J. . 1992. . Democratizing Development: The Role of Voluntary Organisations . , West Hartford , Connecticut : : Kumarian Press. .

            14. Cliff J. . 1993. . ‘Donor‐dependence or donor control? The case of Mozambique’. . Community Development Journal An International Forum . , Vol. 28((3)): 237

            15. Cohen J. . 1991. . ‘Foreign advisors and capacity building: the case of Kenya’. . Public Administration and Development . , Vol. 12:: 493

            16. David Brown L and Covey J. . 1987. . “‘Organising and Managing Private Development Agencies: A Comparative Analysis’. ”. Institution for Social and Policy Studies, Yale University. .

            17. David Brown L and Korten D. . ‘The Role of Voluntary Organizations in Development’. In: . The World Bank, prepared by the Institute for Development Research; . Copenhagen .

            18. de Soto H. . 1989. . The Other Path . , New York : : Harper and Roe. .

            19. Dia M. . 1993. . “‘A Governance Approach to Civil Service Reform in Sub‐Saharan Africa’. ”. World Bank. .

            20. Diamond L. . 1988. . “‘Introduction: Roots of Failure, Seeds of Hope’. ”. In Democracy in Developing Countries: Africa . , Vol. Volume Two. , Boulder , Colorado : : Lynne Rienner Publishers. .

            21. Diamond L, Linz J. , eds. 1988. . Volume Two, Democracy in Developing Countries: Africa . , Boulder , Colorado : : Lynne Rienner Publishers. .

            22. Drucker P. . 1990. . Managing the NonProfit Organisation: Principles and Practices . , New York : : Harper Collins. .

            23. 1995. . ‘The Gift Relationship’. . The Economist . , 18–24 March;

            24. 22–28 July. 1996 . “‘All of a sudden every banker is a World Banker’. ”. 22–28 July. ,

            25. 2–8 November. 1996 . “‘Behind the Zairean Shambles’. ”. 2–8 November. ,

            26. 21–27 September. 1996 . “‘The Gambia, getting away with it’. ”. 21–27 September. ,

            27. Edgcomb E and Cawley J. . 1991. . The Process of Institutional Development: Assisting Small Enterprise Institutions to Become More Effective . , Michigan : : Gemini Development Alternatives, Inc.. .

            28. Edwards M. . 1989. . ‘The Irrelevance of Development Studies’. . Third World Quarterly . , Vol. 11((1)): 116

            29. Edwards M and Hulme M. , eds. 1992. . “’Making a Difference: NGOs and Development in a Changing World’. ”. London : : Earthscan. .

            30. Edwards R. . 1995. . ‘PRA and raised expectations: potentials and pitfalls’. . PLA Notes . , Vol. 22: February;

            31. Esman M and Uphoff N. . 1984. . Local Organisations: Intermediaries in Rural Development . , Ithaca and London : : Cornell University Press. .

            32. Evans P. . 1996. . “‘Government Action, Social Capital and Development: Creating Synergy Across the Public‐Private Divide’. ”.

            33. Farrington J. . 1993. . “Reluctant Partners? NGOs. ”. In The State and Sustainable Agricultural Development . , London : : Routledge. .

            34. Farrington J and Lewis D. . 1993. . Non‐Governmental Organisations and the State in Asia: Rethinking Roles in Sustainable Agricultural Development . , London : : Routledge. .

            35. Fatton R. . 1992. . Predatory Rule, State and Civil Society in Africa . , Boulder , Colorado : : Lynne Rienner. .

            36. Fierlbeck K. . Fetishizing Civil Society. In: . Annual General Meeting of the Canadian Political Science Association; . St. Catherines , Ontario : : Canadian Political Science Association. .

            37. Fowler A. . 1992a. . ‘Distant Obligations: Speculations on NGO Funding and the Global Market’. . Review of African Political Economy . , Vol. 55((9))

            38. 1992b. . Prioritizing Institutional Development: A New Role for NGO Centres for Study and Development . , London : : IIED. .

            39. Fowler A and James R. . 1995. . The Role of Southern NGOs in Development Co‐operation . , Oxford : : Intrac. .

            40. Fuhr H. . Institutional Strengthening on the Local Levels and Donor Coordination: Some Experiences from Latin American Adjustment Policies. In: . VIIth General Conference; . Berlin : : European Association of Development Research and Training Institutes. .

            41. Gaidzanwa R. . 1993. . ‘Citizenship, Nationality, Gender and Class in Southern Africa’. . Alternatives . , Vol. 18((1)): 39

            42. Goetz A. . 1995. . ‘Institutionalizing Women's Interests and Accountability To Women in Development’. . IDS Bulletin . , Vol. 26((3)): 1

            43. Hadenius A and Fuggla. . 1996. . ‘Making Civil Society Work, Promoting Democratic Development: What can States and Donors Do?’. . World Development . , Vol. 24((10)): 1621

            44. Handy C. . 1990. . Understanding Voluntary Organisations . , London : : Penguin Books. .

            45. Held D. . 1991. . “‘Between State and Civil Society’. ”. In Citizenship . , London : : Lawrence and Wishart. .

            46. Herbst J. . 1990. . State Politics in Zimbabwe . , Harare : : University of Zimbabwe Publications. .

            47. Hippler J. . 1995. . The Democratisation of Disempowerment: The Problems of Democracy in the Third World . , London : : Pluto Press. .

            48. Holmen H and Jistrom M. . 1997. . Institutional Development for Rural Development ‐NGOs and the Search for a Growth Panacea . , Stockholm : : SIDA. .

            49. Howes M and Sattar M. . 1992. . “‘Bigger and Better? Scaling‐up strategies pursued by BRAC 1972–1991’. ”. In Making a Difference, NGOs and Development in a Changing World . , p. 99 London : : Earthscan. .

            50. Ignatieff M. . 1995. . “‘The Myth of Citizenship’. ”. In Theorizing Citizenship . , New York : : State University of New York Press. .

            51. James R. . 1995. . Strengthening the Capacity of Southern NGO Partners . , Oxford : : Intrac. .

            52. Lensink R. . 1992. . “‘Recipient Government Behaviour and the Effectiveness of Development Aid Some Evidence on Six Sub‐Saharan African Countries’. ”. Institute of Economic Research, University of Groningen. .

            53. Livernash R.. 1992. . ‘The Growing Influence of NGOs in the Developing World’. . Environment . , Vol. 34((5)): 12

            54. MacGaffey J. . 1992. . “‘Initiatives from Below: Zaire's Other Path to Social and Economic Restructuring’. ”. In Governance and Politics in Africa . , Boulder , Colorado : : Lynne Rienner. .

            55. Meyer C.. 1992. . ‘The Irony of Donor Efforts to Build Institutions: A Case Srudy from the Dominican Republic’. . Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics . , Vol. 148:

            56. Meyer C.. 1992. . ‘A Step Back as Donors Shift Institution Building from the Public to the “Private” Sector’. . World Development . , Vol. 20((8)): 1115

            57. Moore M. . 1989. . ‘The Fruits and Fallacies of neo‐liberalism: the case of Irrigation Policy’. . World Development . , Vol. 17((11)): 1733

            58. Moore M, Stewart S and Hudock A. . 1995. . “‘Institution Building as a Development Assistance Method’. ”. Swedish International Development Agency. .

            59. Mosse D. . December. 1993 . “‘Authority, Gender and Knowledge: Theoretical Reflections on the Practice of Participatory Rural Appraisal’ ODI Agricultural Administration (Research and Extension). ”. December. , p. 31

            60. Muir A. . 1991. . Evaluating the Impact of NGOs in Rural Poverty Alleviation, Zimbabwe Country Study . , London : : ODI. .

            61. Okoth‐Ogendo H. . 1991. . “‘Constitutions without Constitutionalism: Reflections on an African Political Paradox’. ”. In State and Constitutionalism. An African Debate on Democracy . , p. 27 Harare : : SAPES Trust. .

            62. Pratt B and Stone A. . 1995. . Multilateral Agencies and NGOs: A Position Paper . , Oxford : : Intrac. .

            63. Quarles van Ufford P. . 1988. . “‘The Myth of a Rational Development Policy: Evaluation versus Policy‐Making in Dutch Private Donor Agencies’. ”. In The Hidden Crisis in Development: Development Bureaucracies . , Amsterdam : : Free University Press. .

            64. Quarles van Ufford P, Kruijt D. , eds. 1988. . The Hidden Crisis in Development: Development Bureaucracies . , Amsterdam : : Free University Press. .

            65. Roberts H. . 1987. . Editorial. . IDS Bulletin . , Vol. 18((4)): 1

            66. Robinson M. . 1992. . “‘NGOs and Rural Poverty Alleviation: implications for scaling‐up’. ”. In Making a Difference, NGOs and Development in a Changing World . , London : : Earthscan. .

            67. Robinson M. . 1996. . “‘The Emergence of Civil Society’. ”. In Civil Society and Democratisation in Africa: The Potential and Pitfalls of External Intervention . , UK: : University of Warwick. .

            68. Sahley C. . 1995. . Strengthening the Capacity of NGOs: Cases of Small Enterprises Development Agencies in Africa . , Oxford : : Intrac. .

            69. Schuurman F. . 1996. . “‘Introduction: Development Theory in the Nineties’. ”. In New Directions in Development Theory . , London : : ZED Press. .

            70. Schuurman F. , ed. 1996. . New Directions in Development Theory . , London : : ZED Publications. .

            71. SEADD. . 1994. . “‘A Project for Supporting Community Based Organisations in Nepal’. ”. South East Asia Development Division, Overseas Development Agency (SEADD, ODA). .

            72. Seidman A and Seidman R. . 1994. . State and Law in the Development Process Problem‐solving and Institutional Change in the Third World . , London : : Macmillan. .

            73. Shivji I and Human Rights and Constitutionalism. , eds. 1991. . State and Constitutionalism. An African Debate on Democracy . , Harare : : SAPES Trust. .

            74. Shivji I. . 1991. . “‘State and Constitutionalism: A New Democratic Perspective’. ”. In State and Constitutionalism. An African Debate on Democracy . , Harare : : SAPES Trust. .

            75. Skalnes T. . 1995. . The politics of economic reform in Zimbabwe . , Basingstoke : : Macmillan. .

            76. Smith C. . 1989. . Did Colonialism Capture the Peasantry? . , Uppsala : : Scandinavian Institute of African Studies. .

            77. Staudt K. . 1985. . “‘Gender Redistributive Policy’. ”. In Women, Foreign Assistance and Advocacy Administration . , New York : : Praeger. .

            78. Staudt K and Jacquette J. . 1988. . “‘Bureaucratic Resistance to Women's Programmes: The Case for Women in Development’. ”. In Women, Power and Policy . , New York : : Pergammon. .

            79. ( 1997 forthcoming), ‘Cutting Off One's Nose, The Impact of Donor Funding on the Capacity of Indigenous Organisations’ D. phil thesis, IDS: Univ of Sussex .

            80. Tendler J. . 1982. . “‘Turning Private Voluntary Organisations into Development Agencies: Questions for Evaluation’. ”. Edited by: USAID (United States Agency for International Development). .

            81. Thomas L. . 1995. . Urban Poverty and Development Interventions . , Oxford : : Intrac. .

            82. Uphoff N. . 1986. . Local Institutional Development: An Analytical Sourcebook with Cases . , West Hartford , Connecticut : : Kumarian Press. .

            Comments

            Comment on this article