The authors argue that, although purporting to deal with class struggle, the article on ‘Class Struggle and the Periodisation of the State in South Africa’ in ReviewNo. 7 fails to focus its attention on the fundamental contradiction in South African society ‐ that of the struggle between capital and labour. The reason for this inadequacy lies in the article's dependency on the Poulantzian method of analysis which incorrectly separates ‘economics’ and ‘politics’ from the ‘fundamental relations of exploitation’ in capitalist society. It is only by establishing the unity between the relations of exploitation and their manifestation as political and economic forms that the state's position in the class struggle can be correctly located.
Clarke Simon. . ‘Capital, “fractions” of capital and the state: “neo-Marxist” analyses of the South Africa state’. . Capital and Class . ,
Davies Robert and Lewis David. . ‘Industrial Relations Legislation: One of Capital's Defences’. . Review . ,
Stein Mark. . 1978. . ‘The Need for an Industry by Industry Approach to the Study of African Trade Unionism: with particular reference to the Witwatersrand in the 1930s and 1940s’. In: . Paper delivered to the History Workshop; . . 1978 ; . University of Witwatersrand. .